Lancaster County barbecue

Smokehouse at Plain & Fancy Farm

About 6.4 driving miles

A full-service barbecue restaurant at Plain & Fancy Farm serving smoked meats, house sauces, classic sides, local Pennsylvania drinks, and family-style options.

The place

About Smokehouse at Plain & Fancy Farm

Smokehouse at Plain & Fancy Farm is a full-service barbecue restaurant rather than the family-style Pennsylvania Dutch dining room that historically defined the property. The current menu centers on brisket, pulled pork, barbecue chicken, house sauces, mac and cheese, cornbread, and a selection of Pennsylvania beer and wine.

The Smokehouse opened in 2017 as part of the family-operated Plain & Fancy Farm destination. The same property also contains The Amish Experience, lodging, event spaces, and other visitor services, which makes the restaurant a practical meal anchor after a timed program without another drive.

The restaurant currently publishes daily service from 11:30 a.m. to 8 p.m. Walk-ins are welcome, while parties of ten or fewer can reserve online or by phone. Groups of 20 or more use separate private-dining arrangements, and published room capacities range from 34 to 116 depending on configuration.

What stands out

A real meal after the train

Daily lunch-and-dinner hours make this a stronger anchor than a snack stop when the family needs a full meal.

Share the stop with an attraction

The Amish Experience operates on the same Plain & Fancy Farm property, reducing driving between a timed program and dinner.

Lancaster County drinks and barbecue

The current offering combines smoked meats and house sides with local Pennsylvania beer and wine.

Pair it with the train

Why it belongs in a Strasburg Rail Road trip

Smokehouse is about 6.4 driving miles and roughly 15–20 minutes from Strasburg Rail Road before traffic. Put the meal after the train’s firm boarding time, and pair it with The Amish Experience on the same Plain & Fancy Farm property or Kitchen Kettle Village 1.8 miles east.

Before you go

Plan your visit

  • Current hoursThe restaurant currently publishes daily service from 11:30 a.m. to 8 p.m. Recheck for holiday exceptions and same-day changes.
  • ReservationsWalk-ins are welcome. Parties of ten or fewer can reserve through the restaurant’s Resy link or call 717-768-4400.
  • Menu focusSmoked brisket, pulled pork, barbecue chicken, house sauces, classic sides, local Pennsylvania beer and wine, cocktails, and a family feast for four.
  • Dietary needsThe live menu and staff control current ingredients and preparation. Ask about the exact order rather than assuming the entire barbecue menu is allergen-free or gluten-free.
  • AccessibilityThe property says the entrance and dining room have no stairs and accessible restrooms are available. Call ahead for a specific seating or access arrangement.
  • Group diningPrivate dining is for groups of 20 or more; published rooms seat up to 34 or 82 separately and 116 when combined. Arrange directly rather than using a regular table reservation.

On the same property

Add The Amish Experience

Choose a ticketed interpretive program, then walk or reposition on the Plain & Fancy Farm property for the meal.

View the guide →

Useful answers

Frequently asked questions

Is Smokehouse the same as the old Plain & Fancy family-style restaurant?

No. Smokehouse is the property’s current full-service barbecue restaurant, opened in 2017, with its own menu and reservation system.

Do I need a reservation?

Walk-ins are welcome, but a reservation is sensible when the meal must follow a fixed train or tour time. Parties of ten or fewer can book online or call.

Is The Amish Experience nearby?

Yes. It operates on the same Plain & Fancy Farm property, though tickets and restaurant purchases remain separate.

Can the restaurant handle food allergies?

Discuss the exact allergy and order directly with restaurant staff. A limited adjustment mentioned for one event does not establish an allergen-free kitchen or a universal menu rule.

Can a large group eat together?

Private dining is offered for groups of 20 or more, with multiple room capacities. Contact the property for menu, room, deposit, and timing terms.

Trust and accuracy

Sources

Source checked 2026-08-23. This free guide has not yet been confirmed by the venue. Current hours, prices, services, and accessibility can change; confirm time-sensitive details directly.